Back to high court: Prosecutors want state justices to reconsider Karey decision

Prosecutors have asked the state Supreme Court for a rehearing on its recent decision to toss out a 2014 second-degree murder indictment against the man charged with killing pastor Ronald Harris, 51.

Woodrow Karey Jr., 57, is accused of walking into Tabernacle of Praise on Sept. 27, 2013, and shooting Harris twice with a shotgun. He was indicted on one count of manslaughter in November 2013. But prosecutors took the case back to the grand jury in June 2014, resulting in a second-degree murder indictment.

In January 2015, state district court Judge Clayton Davis tossed out the 2014 indictment, agreeing with the defense’s assertion that there had been an understanding by all parties that they would “live with the result of the initial grand jury.”

That ruling, however, was overturned by the 3rd Circuit Court of Appeal in November 2015. The state Supreme Court granted the defense a stay in Karey’s case before his Sept. 12 trial date and heard oral arguments in January.

The high court on June 29 reversed the appellate court’s decision, saying there was “evidence in the record supporting the district court’s factual findings that the defense and the prosecution had a common goal to obtain a manslaughter indictment from the initial grand jury and that there was an ‘understanding’ or agreement between the parties that they would ‘live with’ or be bound by the conclusion of that grand jury.”

The court also said there was no valid justification for prosecutors to withdraw from that understanding and that they had gained an “unfair advantage” when Karey “performed under the agreement, providing witnesses and attorney work product, as well as waiving the spousal privilege as to his wife’s testimony before the grand jury.”

In seeking the rehearing, prosecutor Carla Sigler wrote that the high court “erred in presuming an agreement existed” and that the trial court’s decision to overturn the murder indictment was a “gross abuse of judicial discretion in view of the lack of evidence to support it.”

She also said critical evidence, including the contents of Karey’s phone, had not been obtained by the time of the first indictment.

“There never existed any binding promise that restricted the state from presenting further information to a grand jury as it arose in a continuing investigation,” Sigler wrote.

SportsPlus

life

Salvation Army starts giving season 100 days before Christmas 

Local News

Cassidy: Second assassination attempt ‘beyond concerning’

Business

PPG reaches agreement to sell silicas products business

Local News

Lottery registration for Louisiana Fortify Homes Program grants opens Wednesday

Crime

9/17: Calcasieu Parish Sheriff announces arrest list

Local News

Trump, Harris resume campaigning after apparent assassination attempt

Crime

Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs has been indicted on sex trafficking and racketeering charges

McNeese Sports

Understudy takes center stage

Business

Cameron school employees to get boost in pay

Crime

Fired police officers accused of using racist language

McNeese Sports

McNeese looks to keep momentum

Business

Citgo vice president: Sale of petroleum refiner nearing the finish line

Local News

Sulphur Council hears arguments against borrow pit

McNeese Sports

McDowell earns SLC honors

Crime

Suspect in apparent assassination attempt against Trump charged with federal gun crimes

Local News

‘All good here’ was 1 of the final texts sent from the doomed Titan submersible, hearing reveals

Crime

9/16: Calcasieu Parish Sheriff announces arrest list

life

Jeff Davis Registrar of Voters office to conduct voter registration drives

Local News

Scooter Hobbs column: No work of art but Tigers can build on victory

Crime

UPDATE: FBI says shooting at Trump was an apparent assassination attempt

Crime

Trump safe following shooting at Florida golf course; suspect detained

life

SW La. school lunch menus Sept. 16-20

Business

Names in the News: People shaping the future of Lake Area business

life

Weekend Talk: Grizzlies in Glacier