Bill calls for keeping jurors names secret

The American Press

Secret JuryAmerican Press composite

<p class="indent">Should the names of jurors in Louisiana criminal trials be public records? Legislation making its way through the current session would make it harder to determine how jurors voted in those trials.

<p class="indent">House Bill 699 by Rep. Joe Stagni, R-Kenner, has advocates for press freedom concerned because of the existing 10-2 split jury voting system in Louisiana. Another measure by Sen. J.P. Morrell, D-New Orleans, Senate Bill 243, is a proposed constitutional amendment that would let the state’s voters decide whether to require unanimous juries in felony trials.

<p class="indent">Stagni’s measure passed the House 94-0 and 28-0 in the Senate after being amended by the upper chamber. It must now be either concurred in or rejected by the House and sent to a conference committee to try and settle the differences.

<p class="indent">Jee Park, an attorney with the Innocence Project New Orleans, called the Stagni bill troublesome for the rights of defendants convicted by 10-2 juries.

<p class="indent">Park said, “One of the foundations of our system is that criminal trials are public trials where community members decide a defendant’s fate in the open. This will prevent defendants from uncovering racial bias and other misconduct that occurs during jury deliberations that may have led to convicting an innocent person.”

<p class="indent">Scott Sternberg, an attorney for the Louisiana Press Association and The Advocate, said reporters and citizens need to know how a juror voted, particularly with the state’s current 10-2 decisions.

<p class="indent">An analysis done by The Advocate found that Louisiana’s non-unanimous verdict law disadvantages black defendants more than white ones. It added the system also silences the voices of black jurors, who are more prone than white jurors to dissent from the majority.

<p class="indent">Morrell’s legislation cleared the Senate 27-10, one vote more than the 26 (two-thirds) required for proposed amendments. It has cleared two House committees with unanimous votes and is scheduled for House floor debate on Friday.

<p class="indent">If the Morrell bill passes the House, voters will make the final decision Nov. 6. Approval on that date wouldn’t make Stagni’s measure a major cause for concern because the jury decisions would have to be unanimous. However, as long as 10-2 jury decisions are allowed in criminal cases, it poses problems.

Crime

Family: Woodson didn’t deserve brutality he suffered

Local News

Return home just the start for McNeese basketball

Local News

SW La. school lunch menus Jan. 18-21

Local News

Students get hands-on science lesson on health care

Local News

COVID-related staffing shortages affecting hospitals

Jim Beam

Jim Beam column:’One Small Step’ might do it

Local News

McNeese arena opens for first time since hurricane — and with new name

Local News

Pilot, passenger presumed dead in helicopter crash

Business News

Cassidy critical of Biden’s energy policies

Business News

Police jurors prioritizing feedback to build back better

Crime

1/14: Calcasieu Parish Sheriff announces arrest list

Local News

SW La. nightlife calendar: There’s something to do everyday this weekend

Local News

‘This Same Dusty Road — Huckaby exhibit opens at Historic City Hall

Local News

‘Points of View’ — Dugas exhibit explores connection, how we perceive world

Business

Future plans for SW La. focus of Chamber banquet

Local News

La. to get about $1 billion for bridges from new federal program

Local News

Delton Carter LC’s newest fire chief

Local News

Weekend frontal system could bring storms to SW La.

Business News

Port helps local rice producers deliver to international markets

Local News

UPDATE: COVID shuts down five schools in Allen

Local News

Three Calcasieu schools remain closed due to COVID

Crime

1/13: Calcasieu Parish Sheriff announces arrest list

Local News

Supreme Court halts COVID-19 vaccine rule for US businesses

Local News

BREAKING: Five Allen schools to close Friday due to illnesses