Unanimous jury verdict has our vote

The American Press

The American Press supports proposed constitutional Amendment No. 2 on the Nov. 6 ballot. It would eliminate current 10-2 decisions and require all 12 jurors to reach a unanimous verdict in non-capital felony trials on or after Jan. 1, 2019.

Louisiana and Oregon are the only of two states that don’t require unanimous juries in those cases. The history behind 10-2 decisions is linked to racially-charged attitudes that the state should no longer be supporting.

The state had unanimous jury trials, starting in the early 1800s. However, it was changed during the post-Reconstruction era in the 1880s to have nine jurors agree on a verdict, before being increased to 10 jurors during the 1973 constitutional convention.

Taking away the unanimous jury law made it easier to convict African Americans under Jim Crow-Era laws. However, other southern states didn’t follow suit. For many years, Louisiana has been out of step with the rest of the nation.

Another issue with only requiring 10 jurors to agree involves cases where people are jailed for crimes they didn’t commit. When it comes to sending someone to jail for life, or execution, the entire jury needs to come to a consensus on whether that person is guilty. It’s difficult to say a defendant is convicted beyond a reasonable doubt if there are jurors who are doubtful.

The Public Affairs Research Council’s report on the proposed amendments states that under current law a prosecutor “might over-charge a defendant in order to qualify for a 12-person jury needing 10 votes.” That’s because unanimous decisions are required for juries of six.

Opponents of the amendment argue that even though they don’t agree with the racial history, having the 10-juror requirement leads to fewer mistrials and helps keep the legal system efficient. PAR’s report stated that other countries like England, Scotland, Brazil and others don’t require unanimous juries.

Despite those arguments, it’s time Louisiana updated its law and joined the other 48 states that require unanimous jury verdicts. Amendment No. 2 has drawn widespread support from many organizations and individuals.

When going to the polls on Nov. 6, the American Press urges its readers to vote “yes” for constitutional Amendment 2. It’s long past time to join the rest of the nation in requiring unanimous juries.


This editorial was written by a member of the American Press Editorial Board. Its content reflects the collaborative opinion of the Board, whose members include Crystal Stevenson, John Guidroz, Jim Beam and Mike Jones.””unanimous jury

SportsPlus

Local News

Firefighter training now available for Vernon students

Local News

A rainy-day groundbreaking for the new McNeese Student Union building

Local News

Harris tells Wisconsin crowd election will be ‘a choice between freedom and chaos’

Crime

7/22: Calcasieu Parish Sheriff announces arrest list

life

Back-to-school movie night, supply drive set for Friday

Local News

Johnson on Secret Service director’s resignation: ‘Happy to see she heeded our calls’

Local News

Secret Service director resigns after assassination attempt on Donald Trump

McNeese Sports

Things to watch at Cowboy camp

Local News

Johnson, Jeffries announce bipartisan task force to investigate assassination attempt

Local News

Louisiana Democrats thank Biden, support Harris as new nominee

Local News

Construction on 46-unit Mid-City Lofts begins next month

Local News

Daily showers, thunderstorms expected this week

Crime

7/22: Calcasieu Parish Sheriff announces arrest list

McNeese Sports

New-look Cowboys picked sixth

Local News

Harris praises Biden’s ‘unmatched’ legacy, looks to lock up the Democratic nomination

Business

Tellurian to be acquired by Woodside Energy Group in $900M all-cash payment

Crime

LSU cornerback arrested on accusation of video voyeurism, authorities say

Local News

Secret Service acknowledges denying some past requests by Trump’s campaign for tighter security

Local News

Biden wants to pass baton to Kamala Harris

Local News

BREAKING: Biden drops out of race

Local News

Secret Service chief noted ‘zero fail mission,’ facing calls to resign

Local News

Students explore possible careers in athletic training

Jim Beam

Jim Beam column:Constitution plan resurrected

high-school Sports

New concession stand added to plans for football stadium