Louisiana voting vendor chosen amid bid-rigging complaint

By MELINDA DESLATTE, Associated Press

BATON ROUGE, La. (AP) — Louisiana’s pick to replace thousands of decade-old voting machines is the company that was the subject of bid-rigging complaints involving the secretary of state’s office.

The state’s procurement office sent letters Thursday announcing Colorado-based Dominion Voting Systems is the winning bidder based on “price and other evaluation factors.” Negotiations are set to begin for a contract now estimated to be worth up to $95 million.

Louisiana slowed work to replace the machines and overhauled the team evaluating vendor proposals, after competitor Election Systems and Software raised allegations the secretary of state’s office manipulated the selection process to award the deal to Dominion.

After the complaint was filed, evaluation standards were revised. The procurement office overseeing the contractor selection scrapped the original evaluation committee and removed Secretary of State Kyle Ardoin from it, according to documents reviewed by The Associated Press.

Ardoin said he was involved in revamping the evaluation team and addressing the complaint. However, Jacques Berry, a spokesman for the state procurement office, said the reworking of the evaluation committee was the office director’s “decision unilaterally.”

Ardoin described the selection process as “fair and equitable for all bidders.”

“We look forward to negotiating a final agreement with Dominion in the near future,” he said in a statement Thursday.

Election Systems and Software didn’t say whether the changes addressed all of its concerns. A company attorney cited confidentiality around the ongoing evaluation of proposals. Dominion wouldn’t comment about its winning bid, directing questions to Ardoin’s office.

Competition among companies to replace and service voting machines is fierce. The contracts are lucrative, only a handful of vendors do the work and states hang onto their machines for decades.

Louisiana last purchased voting equipment in 2005. The secretary of state’s office wants to replace existing bulky machines with smaller, touch-screen-style equipment, improved technology and a paper trail. Nearly 10,000 machines are slated to be replaced by 2020.

Three companies bid for the work: Dominion Voting Systems, Hart InterCivic and Election Systems and Software.

Election Systems and Software protested the selection process, objecting to two sets of voting system standards released after the request for proposals from bidders. The standards are highly technical specifications for things such as machine security, ballot counting and voting transmission that contractors must meet.

Election Systems and Software said the secretary of state’s office released add-on standards weeks later than allowed. The company said one set of standards was so specific that only Dominion Voting Systems would qualify.

The standards were “clearly and blatantly slanted to accommodate a single vendor’s existing voting system,” Thomas Clark, a lawyer representing Election Systems and Software, wrote in a protest letter to the Office of State Procurement.

Paula Tregre, director of the procurement office, immediately stalled the evaluation of contract proposals after receiving the complaint. Ardoin withdrew both sets of contested standards two days after the complaint was filed, according to letters exchanged by the officials.

In an interview, Ardoin said one set of standards was signed by former Secretary of State Tom Schedler as he was resigning amid sexual harassment allegations. Ardoin, who was Schedler’s top assistant, took over after Schedler left and said he was unaware Schedler had issued the add-on standards.

“When I was able to figure out what had occurred, I very quickly decided we’re not going to be able to abide by this,” said Ardoin, who is running on the November ballot to remain secretary of state.

Schedler didn’t return a call for comment.

The other standards were “inadvertently uploaded,” Ardoin said. Those were issued for Dominion Voting Systems, for its current work servicing Louisiana’s voting machines and weren’t meant to be required for the new contractor, Ardoin said.

After Ardoin withdrew the contested standards, Tregre directed Ardoin to “remove himself from participating” in the evaluation of voting machine proposals; notified companies the add-on standards won’t be used to evaluate bids; and ordered a new evaluation committee.

Ardoin was named to the evaluation committee when he was Schedler’s chief deputy. He said he asked to be removed because it wasn’t appropriate for the secretary of state to help choose the contractor and then later negotiate final contract terms with the winning bidder.

“We developed this solution together,” he said.

Berry described events differently, saying Tregre “made the decision independent of anything he may or may not have asked. To my knowledge, he didn’t push back on it.”

___

Follow Melinda Deslatte on Twitter at http://twitter.com/melindadeslatte””Voting machine vendor controversy

SportsPlus

Jim Beam

Jim Beam column:Don’t worry. Trump is fixer

Local News

Mayor talks progress, what’s ahead for the city

Local News

EMS Academy, Acadian Ambulance will be offering EMT classes in LC

Local News

City Council candidates for District C state their views

Local News

Capstone at the Oaks senior living complex nearing completion

Local News

FBI says it found 2,400 new JFK assassination records

McNeese Sports

Baseball Preview: Putting pieces in place

McNeese Sports

Shumate rallies Cowboys by ETAM

Business

Trump raises tariffs on aluminum and steel to 25%

Crime

Sheriff issues warrant for Texas man accused of theft

Local News

Parish facility management team strengthening building infrastructure

Crime

LC woman killed in crash with intoxicated driver

Local News

If FEMA didn’t exist, could states handle the disaster response alone?

life

Program uses locally grown produce to help students with healthier eating habits

Crime

2/10: Calcasieu Parish Sheriff announces arrest list

Local News

Trump says he has directed US Treasury to stop minting new pennies, citing rising cost

Local News

Eagles deny Chiefs a three-peat

Local News

Trump says he is serious about Canada becoming 51st state

Business

Names in the News: People shaping the future of Lake Area business

Local News

Crime & punishment: Amendment would allow more juveniles to be tried as adults

Local News

Guest commentary: Executive orders pivot US energy workers from defense to offense

McNeese Sports

Garcia, Parker lead Cowboys

McNeese Sports

Lady Demons drop McNeese

Local News

Lottery registration for Louisiana Fortify Homes Program grants open Feb. 12