Judge denies motion for unanimous verdict in murder case

<p class="p1">Although a trial date has not yet been set for a Lake Charles man accused of second-degree murder, defense attorney Andrew Casanave asked a judge Wednesday to allow special jury instructions regarding the eventual verdict when he does go to trial.</p><p class="p1">Devin Jalmal Holefield, 25, was indicted by a grand jury in 2017 in the fatal shooting of Gary O’Brien, 31, on North Simmons Street on July 17, 2017.</p><p class="p1">Police said at the time that attempted robbery appeared to be the motive for the shooting.</p><p class="p1">Holefield fled the area after the shooting, according to authorities, and was arrested in Waco, Texas, a few days after the incident and was extradited here.</p><p class="p1">He has been incarcerated in the Calcasieu Correctional Center on $1.2 million since his arrest. Others were also indicted in connection with the shooting but will be tried separately.</p><p class="p1">Casanave filed a motion asking Judge Clayton Davis to consider special jury instruction that would require the jury to reach a unanimous verdict when Holefield goes to trial on this charge.</p><p class="p1">“The laws of the Jim Crow era need to change,” Casanave said. “If one-sixth of a jury thinks someone isn’t guilty, we think that is reasonable doubt.”</p><p class="p1">Jim Crow law refers to rules that enforced racial segregation in the South between the end of Reconstruction in 1877 and the beginning of the civil rights movement in the 1950s.</p><p class="p1">Davis said he didn’t necessarily disagree with Casanave but said, “I’m denying the motion because I have to stay within my role,” adding that decisions regarding unanimous verdicts would have to be made by the Legislature.</p><p class="p1">Louisiana is one of only two states that does not require a unanimous verdict in a trial, with Oregon being the other.</p>

Local News

Portion of La. in Lake Arthur renamed in honor of Fox

Local News

La. abortion ban holds in court once again

Crime

UPDATE: Husband, wife both charged with molestation, cruelty

life

Classes back in session: Lake Charles Charter begins 12th year

Crime

UPDATE: Reward offered in Oakdale homicide

life

Gerald Sims: A neighborly neighbor that others can count on

Crime

One arrested, one sought in molestation case

Local News

Two Police Jury buildings closed due to water main break

Local News

La. continues to average 1,500-3,000 COVID cases daily

Crime

Nephew arrested after fight with uncle

Local News

Drink and Draw: CYPHACON social event allows ‘like-minded geeks’ to gather, have fun

Local News

Fort Polk name change could cost $1.4M

Local News

Kathleen Mayo: She’s had passion for teaching since age 9

Local News

Seersucker and a Solitaire: Lively fundraiser to benefit St. Nicholas Center for Children

Jim Beam

Jim Beam column: Focus on children, families

life

Attention to detail, respect for ingredients come naturally to Calla chef

Local News

CPSB cybersecurity breach investigation handed over to DA

Crime

Cpt. Darbonne mentors young students against violence, bullying

life

McNeese’s Victory Day celebrates kids with special needs

Local News

Photo Gallery: McNeese Football ‘Victory Day’

Local News

Body of missing canoeist recovered from Ouiska Chitto Creek

Crime

8/9: Calcasieu Parish Sheriff announces arrest list

Business

Pain at the Pump: Panelists give input on why gas prices have gotten so high

Crime

Charges upgraded in Oakdale shooting