Appeals Court upholds conviction, life sentence in carjacking of man who tried to help after accident

The state’s Appeals Court has affirmed the conviction and life sentence of an Oakdale man who attacked and carjacked a passerby who had stopped to help two people at the scene of an overturned vehicle on La.10.

Arnold Ray Goudeau was convicted by a jury in September 2022 on a charge of carjacking and later sentenced to life imprisonment at hard labor without benefit of probation, parole or suspension as a habitual offender in September 2023.

The conviction and sentence stem from an incident in November 2021 in which the victim had stopped to assist a couple at the scene of an overturned vehicle on La. 10 near the water treatment plant in Oakdale.

After helping the two occupants out of the car, the victim testified the couple tried to convince him to bring them to Oakdale, although he insisted they call police and paramedics to check on their condition. The victim said he was followed to his vehicle by the pair and attacked by Goudeau, who stole his car.

The car was later found abandoned about three miles from the scene.

Goudeau was found guilty of carjacking in the 31st Judicial District Court in September 2022 and sentenced to life in prison.

A charge of theft of a motor vehicle was dismissed.

In an appeal to the Third Circuit Court of Appeal, Godeau and his attorney, Gregory Cook, argued that the original trial judge should have excused himself because he was the prosecutor in a previous criminal matter involving Goudeau.

In addition, they contend the trial court erred by allowing the state to charge him with a different crime than the one he confessed to committing and that the trial court gave confusing and inconsistent jury instructions causing the jury to find him guilty of carjacking on insufficient evidence. They further contend the trial court erred in failing to advise Goudeau of his rights prior to the habitual offender hearing and that the trial court erred in allowing the hearing.

After reviewing the claims, the Appeals Court judges recently found the claims lacked merit and affirmed the conviction, habitual offender adjudication and sentence.

McNeese Sports

Ex-Cowboy King promoted to Astros

Jim Beam

Jim Beam column:Contributions buy results

life

DeRidder High graduate latest $10,000 Sunny Brown Scholarship recipient

Local News

Louisiana becomes first state to allow surgical castration as punishment for child molesters

Crime

Suspect in Benoit Motors dealership fire sought

Local News

La. faces lawsuits over mandatory display of 10 Commandments

life

PHOTO GALLERY: It’s alligator feeding time — check out this action

Local News

Finger out of joint: Damaged metal to blame for bridge shutdown

life

SW La. nightlife calendar: There’s always something to do

Crime

6/21: Calcasieu Parish Sheriff announces arrest list

life

Vietnam service members, their families to be honored Saturday

life

Starkid Productions comedy coming to ACTS Theatre stage

life

‘Ain’t Misbehavin’: LCLT opens Fats Waller musical today at Southlake Theater

Crime

Judge: More accountability needed for juvenile offenders in SW La.

life

House of worship, closed for more than four years, set to reopen Saturday

Local News

Tropical Storm Alberto dissipates after heavy rains kill 4

Local News

Casssidy: Bill would ‘dismantle’ DEI efforts

Local News

Fontenot signs with Cowgirls

life

Free summer concert: LCCB presents’ A Night at the Movies’

Crime

LC pair sent to prison for federal firearms, drug offenses

Crime

6/20: Calcasieu Parish Sheriff announces arrest list

life

PHOTO GALLERY: A magic moment

Crime

Two teenagers charged in robbery in which female was shot

Local News

Some memories don’t fade away: LC’s Dark recalls legendary Mays