Hickey: Grading the Cowboys at the midpoint of season

By By Alex Hickey / American Press

The midpoint of McNeese State’s football season will technically come at halftime of next week’s game against Central Arkansas.

Unfortunately, this presents an awkward time to publish a midterm report card for the Cowboys, so you’ll just have to deal

with the fact we’re providing you one a full 30 minutes ahead of schedule.

QUARTERBACK (Grade: B+): If Cody Stroud isn’t the most valuable player for McNeese, he is certainly the most improved. Stroud has gone from the bottom

of the Southland Conference in passing efficiency to near the top. He’ll match last season’s total with one more touchdown

pass, and is making more plays with his legs than ever before. He’s about as effective a game manager as one can be now.

He’s had a few misfires, but even the

two interceptions he’s thrown were the result of great defensive plays

rather than horrible

throws.The most glaring negative was his inability to connect on

four consecutive cracks at the end zone to end the first half at

Southeastern Louisiana. Completing any one of them likely would

have erased McNeese’s lone loss. Ultimately, though, that

says more about how well he has done — the Cowboys are one play

away from being undefeated.


It’s been an outstanding showing for the rushing attack, which is

averaging 247.4 yards per game. The Cowboys have the most

diverse rushing arsenal in the conference, with all three members

of the BMW backfield — (Champlain) Babin, (Javaris) Murray

and (Marcus) Wiltz — ranked in the top eight in the league

individually. It’s no coincidence the lone loss came in the lone

game when only two of the three could play.

The Cowboys need better ball protection from Babin, however. He’s lost a fumble in three consecutive games, which takes the

group down from a full-blown A grade.


If you get the ball into the hands of one of McNeese’s wideouts, odds

are it will be a first down. Stroud’s top three receiving

targets are each averaging at least 15 yards per catch. There have

been a few key drops here and there, but nothing that has

killed the Cowboys.


The tight ends don’t have a ton of catches, but they know how to make

them count. Two of Josh Jordan’s five catches are touchdowns,

as is one of Kendale Thomas’ three grabs. Thomas also had a key

grab on the successfully executed 2-minute drill to end the

first half against Weber State.

OFFENSIVE LINE (A): After a tough 2011, the line reasserted itself to start the season as the Cowboys ran for at least 290 yards in their first

three games. The line looked its best during an 18-play, 64-yard drive against Northwestern State that took 9 minutes off

the clock — although ultimately the Cowboys had to settle for a field goal.

McNeese is second in the conference in sacks allowed with six through five games. The Cowboys rated seventh in the league

last year, allowing 37 in 11 games.

DEFENSIVE LINE (A+): McNeese is tops in the league against the run, allowing 2.1 yards per carry. Sophomore end Everett Ellefsen has been huge

with seven tackles for loss. The line has contributed seven of the team’s nine sacks, with three coming from Ellefsen. The

Cowboys had 11 sacks all of last season.


group has played a key role in run support. Deonte Thompson and Hayden

Dobbs each rank in the top four on the team in

tackles. Joe Narcisse has battled injuries but is the defense’s

emotional leader. He leads the linebackers with three tackles

for loss despite missing most of two games. His biggest TFL came

in the opener at Middle Tennessee, which forced the Blue

Raiders to kick a field goal after marching inside the 5 on their

first possession.


There’s been plenty of big plays, like Guy Morgan’s key interception at

Weber State, Ford Smesny’s pick to beat Northwestern

State and Chris Raggett setting a school record with a pair of

interception returns for scores against McMurry. Terrence Cahee

has been everywhere, breaking up seven passes — no other Cowboy

has more than two.

Injuries have certainly hurt this

group, though. McNeese could not stop Southeastern Louisiana on

third-and-long in the second

half without Morgan, Smesny and Malcolm Bronson on the field. The

Cowboys also allowed a pair of 40-yard-plus touchdown passes

against Northwestern. The bye week should provide more reps for

backups and a chance for Morgan to get closer to 100 percent.

SPECIAL TEAMS (C): Good or bad, you can’t take your eyes off the special teams unit.

Freshman Jean Breaux has been a

revelation with three punts longer than 50 yards and nine downed inside

the opposing 20. Opposing

punters have downed McNeese inside its own 20 five times. Breaux

has also sent 11 kickoffs into the end zone for touchbacks.

He’ll have to send even more over the goal line in the second half of the year, because when opponents have returned a McNeese

kickoff it has been largely disastrous. The Cowboys are 109th in the nation in defending kick returns, allowing an average

27.48-yard run back.

Josh Lewis has been up and down,

hitting seven of his 12 field-goal attempts with one blocked. Another

was wiped out by a

false-start penalty that pushed the Cowboys back 5 yards and

resulted in a miss, yet another play that would have beaten SLU.

The Cowboys have converted a first down on a fake punt, and allowed a pair on fake punts in consecutive weeks.

An illegal substitution on a SLU extra-point attempt allowed the Lions to move closer to the goal line and go for 2 and the

25-24 win.

Any semblance of consistency is a must for the special teams in the second half.

COACHING (B-): Offensive line coach Rob Sale and defensive line coach Manny Michel have done a fantastic job turning those units around this

season. Head coach Matt Viator’s offseason work with Stroud has also paid off. Starting the year with a win over a quality

Football Bowl Subdivision opponent is also a feather in the coaching staff’s hat.

In terms of strategy, there is room for improvement. Viator admitted to getting too conservative against Middle Tennessee

State in the fourth quarter, which combined with a long kickoff return allowed the Blue Raiders to get back into the game.

He also said he needed to make better calls at the end of the first half the past two games.

McNeese was in position for touchdowns that could have knocked out SLU and Northwestern State, but settled for field goals

on each occasion to provide the opponent with momentum.

If the Cowboys have a chance to go for

the jugular in their next three games — against UCA, at Sam Houston

State and then

against Stephen F. Austin — they must grab it. At the end of the

season, those three games will have the most bearing on how

this team grades out.


Alex Hickey covers McNeese State athletics. Email him at ahickey@americanpress.com