Editorial: Federal lawsuit over voucher program perplexing

The federal government’s decision to sue the state of Louisiana over its implementation of its school voucher program befuddles.

The U.S. Department of Justice late last week filed a petition in federal court to block the 2014-2015 vouch program, claiming

that the program runs counter to the federal desegregation order that has been in place for decades in Louisiana.

The voucher program, initiated for the 2012-2013 school year, allows low-income students attending public schools graded C,

D or F to use state money to transfer to private schools.

In its petition, the Justice Department says the state of Louisiana did not ‘‘consult with or obtain authorization’’ from

federal courts overseeing the desegregation orders before handing out the vouchers. It points out that vouchers have been

awarded to students in at least 22 school districts operating under school desegregation orders that date back at least 35


State officials, though, point out that the desegregation order, in part, prevented state money from being used to enable

white students to escape racially mixed schools.

State Superintendent of Education John White pointed out the irony, saying that the vast majority of students who are using

vouchers are black.

‘‘ ... We’ve got a scholarship program:

100 percent of the kids are low-income, 100 percent of the kids are in

failing schools

— C, D, or F schools, 90 percent of the kids are minorities,’’

said Gov. Bobby Jindal. ‘‘Eight thousand of those parents have

chosen to take these dollars and send their kids to better

schools, to other schools where they can get a better education,

where it is a better fit for their children.

‘‘Now the Department of Justice is

using the same rules that were there to prevent discrimination against

minority children

and is going after some of these parents and some of these kids

and saying, ‘we don’t know that we want to allow you to make

this choice. We want you to have to go a federal judge.’ We need

to provide a great education for every child.”

The voucher program certainly has

issues. Calling it a scholarship program is flat out wrong — there’s no

scholarship or earning

of the voucher money by a student on merit. Its first-year

implementation was clumsy with several school applicants being

exposed by newspapers around the state as being ill-prepared to

host students. And there’s the question of whether the voucher

program violates the Louisiana Constitution by allowing public

funds to be directed to private education.

But the federal government, in this case, appears to be lawyerin’ up the wrong tree.

It’s frivolous at best and points to the lack of homework on the part of the federal government. This decision will likely

cost federal and state dollars on a petition that should have never been filed.

• • •

This editorial was written by a member of the American Press Editorial Board. Its content reflects the collaborative opinion of the Board, whose members include Bobby Dower, Jim Beam, Crystal Stevenson and Donna Price.